if you supports trans rights, you must accept trans wrongs.
Sexual/gender identity is not inherently coupled to radical politics and to suggest that any who do not fall out of the closet into hammer-and-sickle thigh-highs is some kind of faker is some short sighted shit.
While I partially agree with this, it’s a little bit reductionist.
While it’s true that sexual/gender identity is not Inherently coupled to radical politics, the contradictions are clear. Reactionary / liberal trans people are subjecting themselves to a contradiction - the contradiction between sympathy and reality. By being a liberal as a trans person, you are sympathizing with liberalism, and are contradicted with the reality of liberalism - that liberalism at best feels indifferent to transgender people and at worst feels complete and utter disgust for them.
So, it definitely is pushing you towards radical politics if you are not a straight or cis person in the modern day and age.
The gender binary is a construct made to aid capitalism. Transphobia exist therefore to maintain the gender binary. But being a member of an oppressed group (which in this case “white trans people” interacts in its own unique way with the construct of whiteness) is not a magical wand to make you a communist and never supportive (consciousnessly or not) of empire.
if you supports trans rights, you must accept trans wrongs.
Sexual/gender identity is not inherently coupled to radical politics and to suggest that any who do not fall out of the closet into hammer-and-sickle thigh-highs is some kind of faker is some short sighted shit.
While I partially agree with this, it’s a little bit reductionist.
While it’s true that sexual/gender identity is not Inherently coupled to radical politics, the contradictions are clear. Reactionary / liberal trans people are subjecting themselves to a contradiction - the contradiction between sympathy and reality. By being a liberal as a trans person, you are sympathizing with liberalism, and are contradicted with the reality of liberalism - that liberalism at best feels indifferent to transgender people and at worst feels complete and utter disgust for them.
So, it definitely is pushing you towards radical politics if you are not a straight or cis person in the modern day and age.
The gender binary is a construct made to aid capitalism. Transphobia exist therefore to maintain the gender binary. But being a member of an oppressed group (which in this case “white trans people” interacts in its own unique way with the construct of whiteness) is not a magical wand to make you a communist and never supportive (consciousnessly or not) of empire.