A review should at bare minimum be evaluating something about the game though. How useful is it if someone plays Pokémon Gold and then rates it low because they saw Totodile and said “I don’t like crocodiles.” They’re reviewing themselves at that point, not the game.
The review in your example is useful if I’m looking for a game with crocodiles, or I’m looking for a game without crocodiles. That is evaluating the game, just with narrow criteria.
A review should at bare minimum be evaluating something about the game though. How useful is it if someone plays Pokémon Gold and then rates it low because they saw Totodile and said “I don’t like crocodiles.” They’re reviewing themselves at that point, not the game.
The review in your example is useful if I’m looking for a game with crocodiles, or I’m looking for a game without crocodiles. That is evaluating the game, just with narrow criteria.