A Scottish women’s charity said Carpenter’s new album cover evokes “tired tropes” of women being “possessions,” while fans have defended her cover as satirical commentary on sexism.
Right ok but that’s not really the kind of satire we’re talking about is it? I mean, we can get technical about word definitions or we can talk about what we’re actually criticising which is a specific strain of content that depicts something that is only understood to be humour/critique when looking at the subtext of the content using some sort of media literacy.
My point here is that if you don’t need to analyse or read subtext to understand it’s satire, it’s not what we’re talking about when we say satire doesn’t work.
Right ok but that’s not really the kind of satire we’re talking about is it? I mean, we can get technical about word definitions or we can talk about what we’re actually criticising which is a specific strain of content that depicts something that is only understood to be humour/critique when looking at the subtext of the content using some sort of media literacy.
My point here is that if you don’t need to analyse or read subtext to understand it’s satire, it’s not what we’re talking about when we say satire doesn’t work.