I think charging money for pirated content is crossing the line. Once you do it for profit, you put a target on your back for the work’s author to aim for.

Copyright infringement for me but not for thee.

I pirate because I’m broke, so, not gonna happen… 😄

To me it seems fine, especially if there’s still a free version that’s basically the same or it gets released after a delay. I don’t think I’d pay for something like this myself, and maybe they’re taking some legal risk, but if the money lets them spend time making media accessible, how is there a problem that outweighs the good?