That’s a really uncharitable view, and absolutely not the stance of the MUG on Palestinian resistance. I’m p sure MUG are closer to orthodox Marxism than Trotskyism too.
It’s an informed view based on numerous personal interactions with MUG members, including parts of leadership. They are internally incoherent. They’ve adopted better lines, largely being dragged there by Red Star and circumstance, but as you can see they will gladly build a unity platform with explicit Trotskyists instead of the many ML factions. A unity platform that, again, aligns with their absurdly idealist and just plain silly “amend the constitution” plank.
That’s a really uncharitable view, and absolutely not the stance of the MUG on Palestinian resistance. I’m p sure MUG are closer to orthodox Marxism than Trotskyism too.
It’s an informed view based on numerous personal interactions with MUG members, including parts of leadership. They are internally incoherent. They’ve adopted better lines, largely being dragged there by Red Star and circumstance, but as you can see they will gladly build a unity platform with explicit Trotskyists instead of the many ML factions. A unity platform that, again, aligns with their absurdly idealist and just plain silly “amend the constitution” plank.